Doug Henwood Talks

http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3288355,00.html

Reporter: Israel deliberately not destroying launchers

Top Washington Post military reporter Tom Ricks severely criticized
after suggesting Israel is intentionally leaving Hizbullah rocket
launchers intact to maintain moral defense to strike civilian targets
in Lebanon

Yitzhak Benhorin

WASHINGTON - Tom Ricks, military reporter for the Washington Post,
accused Israel Tuesday of intentionally failing to destroy a number
of rocket launchers in south Lebanon, to maintain a moral defense to
its striking civilian of targets in Lebanon.

Ricks, who was awarded a Pulitzer Prize in journalism and recently
published his new book “Fiasco” on the failure of the American war in
Iraq, made the comments during an interview on CNN.

Ricks, who was hosted on the Howard Kurtz’s weekly media review show
on the CNN news network, said: “Civilian casualties are also part of
the battlefield play for both sides here. One of the things that is
going on, according to some US military analysts, is that Israel
purposely has left pockets of Hizbullah rockets in Lebanon, because
as long as they’re being rocketed, they can continue to have a sort
of moral equivalency in their operations in Lebanon.”

Shocked by the prominent commentator’s accusation, interviewer Howard
Kurtz replied, “hold on, you’re suggesting that Israel has
deliberately allowed Hizbullah to retain some of it’s fire power,
essentially for PR purposes, because having Israeli civilians killed
helps them in the public relations war here?”

Since Ricks made the comments, he has been assailed by numerous
organizations which monitor representations of Israel in the United
States media. Ricks was also criticized in American radio shows,
which represent generally America’s conservative right-wing population.

Rush Limbaugh, who hosts the most popular radio show in the US – with
an audience of over 12 million listeners (for the sake of comparison,
CNN has 1 million viewers at peak hours), devoted a full one-hour
program to the foreign media’s hostile treatment of Israel.

Limbaugh discussed the scandal of a Reuters photographer who touched
up photographs of the destruction in Lebanon for the first half hour
of the program. The second half hour was devoted to the Washington
Post’s military correspondent Ricks.

‘Israeli public would never accept it’

During an interview for Hugh Hewitt’s popular website, on which Ricks
book Fiasco was being promoted, the Washington Post journalist was
again asked about his severe charges against Israel. I wish I had
kept my mouth shut, Ricks said, but added: Everything I said was
accurate.

Ricks noted than in an off-the-record conversation with a number of
military analysts, two of them said they believed it was a clever
strategy on the part of Israel to leave a few rocket launchers intact
to aid Israel in sharpening public sentiment and give Israeli forces
more freedom to operate.

The analysts didn’t think it was a bad strategy, Ricks noted. Rather,
they believed it would be a clever move on the part of Israel if it
were true.

Later, however, Ricks attempted to distance himself from the
statements. I have heard from a number of very knowledgeable and
intelligent people that while such a strategy could be logical and
even morally defensible, Ricks said, of course the Israeli public
would never accept it.

He said Israelis had criticized his comments were irresponsible.

When asked to reveal his sources, Ricks refused. It was an off-the- record conversation, and I must keep my word, he said.

(08.08.06, 19:56)

This entry was posted on Wednesday, August 9th, 2006 at 3:04 pm and is filed under Uncategorized. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.